Hello dear
Welcome To Creno's Pizza
Creno's Pizza, nestled in New Concord, Ohio, is a local gem that offers an array of delicious, high-quality pizzas and subs. Their signature Deluxe Pizza boasts a hearty topping of pepperoni, sausage, and fresh veggies, while the unique Sugardale BLT Pizza combines mozzarella with bacon and lettuce for a refreshing twist. Generous portions, like their impressive XL calzone, add to the appeal, alongside beloved sides like cheesy garlic bread. Patrons rave about the consistent quality and friendly service, making Creno’s a favorite for dine-in and pickup. With a welcoming atmosphere and quick service, it's a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Build Your Own Pizza
Mug Root Beer
Lemon Tea
Dr Pepper Cream Soda
About
Creno's Pizza
Creno's Pizza, located in the heart of New Concord, Ohio, has become a beloved staple for pizza enthusiasts in the area, and for good reason. Nestled at 13 E Main St, this cozy eatery boasts a menu that caters to a variety of tastes while maintaining a commitment to quality. With a focus on fresh ingredients and friendly service, Creno's is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a community hub where great food and customer satisfaction come together.
The highlight of Creno's menu is undoubtedly its build-your-own pizza option. Starting at just $6.60, you can customize your pie with an array of toppings and the perfect layer of cheese and sauce. If you’re in the mood for something pre-designed, the Hot Clucker Pizza and the Wild BBQ Chicken Pizza are customer favorites, featuring mouthwatering chicken and a blend of savory flavors that will leave your taste buds craving more. For veggie lovers, the Veggie Pizza, laden with fresh toppings, offers a delightful crunch with every bite.
But Creno's Pizza doesn’t stop at just pizza. Their sides, like the zesty Buffalo Chips, provide a unique twist to traditional sides with finely sliced potatoes seasoned to perfection. And let’s not overlook the garlic bread with cheese—an essential companion to any pizza order. A meal at Creno's isn't complete without indulging in their famous cinnamon breadsticks, which customer Marie Crum aptly describes as "absolutely delicious."
Their subs, including the savory Turkey Club and the classic Ham and Cheese, offer hearty alternatives to pizza, packed with flavors that rival even their signature pies. With prices that are family-friendly and generous portion sizes, every meal feels like a celebration.
Customers rave about the consistency and quality at Creno's. Brody Tuttle describes it as "the best pizza in the area by far," praising the perfectly melted cheese and well-balanced crust. It's clear that over the years, Creno’s has honed its craft, delivering reliable and delicious pizzas that keep locals coming back for more. The welcoming service, as noted by Kaci Uran, adds to the experience, making every visit feel personal and special.
If you’re looking for a place that combines great food, a friendly atmosphere, and quick service, look no further than Creno's Pizza. Whether you dine in, takeout, or opt for delivery (just keep in mind the potential wait), Creno's is a gateway to genuine pizza pleasure in New Concord.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The pizza is superb and the cinnamon breadsticks are absolutely delicious ”
“ Best pizza in the area by far. They've only improved over the years we've been here. They have high quality toppings. The cheese is perfectly melted, the crust isn't too chewy or too crunchy. And it only takes about 30mins max for pickup! Only get delivery if you're close to the restaurant though, as the delivery is slow from our experience. ”
“ My son was craving crenos (nothing different from the daily lol) and we happened to be in new Concord so we stopped in and the manager was absolutely amazing. You wanna talk about the perfect employee and worker of the year it was definitely him. He was so sweet and just the absolute best. Even though we live in Cambridge I think we'll order from here :) ”
“ Had the xl calzone. Was huge about a 16in pizza that was folded full of cheese, sausage and pepperoni. Place is small 2 larger tables, 2 tall tops. Service was great, people were super r friendly. Lots of people picking up online orders. ”
“ This is our go-to some nights for pizza. Their pizza is always made the same which is a good thing. You know what you're going to get. The staff is friendly. Delivery is quick as well. ”
“ Called in and made an order. The staff was able to answer my questions and make recommendations towards what I needed. The food was ready in a timely manner and the staff was friendly when I was in the location. The food was delicious. The wings and pizza were made fresh and had great flavor! Thank you. ”
“ Pizza was very good and hot! Salad was tasty and fresh! Staff was courteous, pleasant and friendly! Food was ready when we arrived to pick it up! I would order from here again when back in the area! ”
“ My family gets a lot of pizza from these guys. Thin pizza with good toppings always hot and addicting. Prices are descent. Easy to get to from main street. We always call ahead on way in to town so we won't have to wait. ”